Businesspeople working in meeting

Board of Directors


Online Banking

DAVID A. COFFEY has served as President and Chief Executive Officer of Mutual Savings Bank since 2018. He joined Mutual in 1998 and previously served the capacity of Executive Vice President, Chief Operating Officer and Chief Financial Officer. David is a graduate of Franklin College.

ANGELA COY joined the Board in 2019. She has been a partner of Compass Pointe CPA’s, Greenwood, since 2010 and is a member of the American Institute of CPA’s and the Indiana CPA Society. Angela is a graduate of Leadership Johnson County, for which she has served six years on the board and two years as president.

Jeff Goben

JEFF GOBEN joined the Board in 2017. He retired in 2014 after a 41-year banking career in Johnson County. As a co-founder of Heartland Community Bank, he served as Executive Vice President and Chief Operating Officer. Jeff is active in the community and received the honor of Distinguished Hoosier by the Governor of Indiana in 2016.

LYNNETTE GRAY joined the Board in 2019. She is a director emeritus of the Indiana Trial Lawyers Association; a member of the Indianapolis and American bar associations; past vice president of the Johnson County Bar Association and more. Lynnette earned an undergraduate degree from Ball State University and a JD from Indiana University-Indianapolis.

Bank employee bob heuchan

ROBERT D. HEUCHAN serves as Vice Chairman of the Board, his tenure in this position began in 1999. He served as President and Chief Executive Officer of Mutual from 1991-2017. Robert is a graduate of Franklin College and has an MBA from the University of Indianapolis.

Bank employee kyle kasting

KYLE E. KASTING joined the Board in 2014. He started Midwest Communications Group in 2007, helping advocacy groups, government officials and candidates communicate with voters. Born and raised on his family’s farm in Franklin, Kyle attended Purdue University.

Bank employee Jerry Petro

JERRY D. PETRO has served as a director of Mutual Savings Bank since 1997 and Third Century Bancorp since 2004. As of May 15, 2019, he was elected as Chairman of the Board. Petro is a retired entrepreneur. Prior to his retirement, Jerry owned commercial real estate for light industrial use, bottle water distribution businesses and commercial coatings businesses. Jerry is a graduate of Franklin College and Indiana University (M.S.).

Bank employee rob schafstall

ROBERT D. SCHAFSTALL has served as a member of the Board of Directors of Third Century since its formation in March 2004 and of Mutual since 1999. Robertl retired from his service as a Franklin City Judge and has been an attorney in the law firm of Cutsinger and Schafstall since 1972.

Contact Us

317-736-7151

Need to Reorder Checks?
Click Here

Looking to Apply for a Loan online?

Click Here to apply for a Loan

Refer a Friend

Refer a Friend

Mobile Banking

Download our new mobile app on your smart phone or tablet.

Download on the App Store Get it on Google Play